Noise Blog

Noisey Thoughts: “Checking In”

A fresh take on location marketing opportunities

September 1st, 2010 / Posted by: brett
Photo Credit: Gord McKena

Photo Credit: Gord McKena

A host of location sharing applications have hit the market over the last couple of years. Though only 4% of U.S. Internet users  checked in to location social networks in July 2010 1, the dominance of the smartphone, introduction of Facebook Places, and emergence of location based e-coupon services point to new sharing trend in 2011.

To offer a different perspective on emerging location-based opportunities, I looked at two location “check-in” applications through the lens of an out-of-home planning theory known as Life Pattern Marketing.

In the digital world, media planners have the ability to track behaviors in real time. People’s actions in the physical world are not nearly as traceable. That may be changing.

Mobile check-in applications, if used regularly, become outlines of individuals’ daily adventures throughout the physical world. If a person enters a physical space, he or she can check into a given digital application for some kind of social or commercial benefit.  As a result, insight that we’ve never previously had access to becomes available thanks to users who choose to publicize their data.

Life Pattern Marketing

This opens up the idea of delivering contextually relevant messages during a consumer’s daily life journey. This tactic is the premise of a planning theory known as Life Pattern Marketing2.

In short, LPM recommends planners:

courtsey of seesaw networks

(1)    Map out the daily work, play, and social tasks of a given demographic;

(2)    Review relevant advertising opportunities;

(3)    Develop contextually relevant executions that intercept the target during a daily pattern.

How does LPM Interplay with two popular applications?

Facebook Places:

Facebook places allows users to check-in to a location with or without friends.  Each check-in is then published to a user’s news feed and broadcasted to his/her network of friends.

Commercial locations can also be claimed by the rightful owners. These Place pages will become hubs for fans, reviews, ratings and deals. Eventually, the Place page will merge with the Facebook ‘brand page’ to become one virtual hub.

LPM opportunities:

If a person opts in to a promotion or value-added service, his/her data could be used to deliver targeted, geo-relevant messages to a variety of screens (mobile phone, digital out of home screens, retail).

Continued usage will develop a pattern of activity that could be sold (with permission, anonymously, and in exchange for value) to companies looking to harvest life pattern data.

E-coupon companies (another buzzword for 2011) may develop applications that review your daily life patterns and prescribe targeted product deals to fit your needs.  Similar types of location-based game applications may also emerge.

Shopkick:

Shopkick is a mobile application that offers in-store deals at partner retailers. Users download the application and are given ‘kickbucks’ for checking into stores. Enter the brilliant part: Shopkick has installed digital terminals at all of their retail partners so when shoppers enter they are automatically alerted of the deals available.

Note: One problem I have with Shopkick (and other similar apps) is that it’s yet another loyalty points system. I think most folks would rather have one or two integrated loyalty points systems that all work together rather than hundreds of one-offs.

LPM opportunities:

Even though Shopkick is more about users’ commercial adventures, widespread adoption may lead to very interesting (and more readily available) data. The unnatural step of manually ‘checking-in’ is removed and the number of interactions may increase as a result.

If Shopkick goes main-stream, planners may gain insight on when and why different shoppers travel to commercial spaces. This again could be leveraged across digital out-of-home and in-store digital channels in a way that syncs with the application.

Final Thoughts:

Sharing location – whether it’s to a group of friends or to a commercial entity -  may seem like an unnatural behaviour at the moment (too many barriers in the way, too many privacy issues, etc.) but as intuitive applications that add social and material value continue to emerge, this act seems primed to become normalized.

Summary of key considerations:

  • Manage expectations: this trend is still in its early days but worth experimenting with.
  • Add value: how does the mechanic envisioned add social or material value?
  • Remove barriers: Incentivize check-ins and reviews.
  • Map out your target audience’s life pattern: location applications should be considered because they are relevant to a consumers’ behaviour.
  • Think multi-screen: how can location data be leveraged across multiple screens & platforms en route to purchase.

Sources:

(1)    Location-Based Social Networks: A Hint Of Mobile Engagement. (July 2010) Forrester.

(2)    Monty Zwebeni (2010) Life Pattern Marketing http://www.seesawnetworks.com/services/whitepapers/life-pattern-marketing/

Branding Gaga

Inspired by Lady Gaga’s concert at Roger’s Arena, this blog post is about branding Gaga.

August 24th, 2010 / Posted by: Vanessa

Lady Gaga and Miracle WhipHardly anyone has heard of Stefani Joanne Angelina Germanotta, yet her persona as Lady Gaga has skyrocketed this 23 year old musician to global fame.  According to Forbes Magazine, Lady Gaga isn’t the music industry’s new Madonna – she’s its new business model.

And there’s no qualms in the music industry in outrightly labeling Lady Gaga as a brand – no different from how a marketing company would treat “Samsung or Target,” says Steve Stoute, an industry expert on linking brands to bands. “We’re treating her exactly the same way, building her brand story and finding the right partnerships…“ Stoute, who has previously negotiated partnerships between Justin Timberlake + McDonald’s and Jay-Z + Reebok, signed Lady Gaga on as a Viva Glam spokesperson for Mac Cosmetics; the lipstick outsold every launch in Viva Glam’s 16-year history.

With over 16 million fans on Facebook and 5.7 million Twitter followers (beating out Britney Spears as Queen of Twitter), Lady Gaga is certainly a jackpot for brand influence.  For example, the music video for Telephone is a cesspool for product placement.  Over 10 brands make an appearance in this music video.  Scenes with a Virgin Mobile cellphone is an extension of Lady Gaga’s “Monster Ball” tour sponsorship, while appearances of Polaroid acknowledges her new role as the company’s creative director.  Meanwhile, Miracle Whip with its revamped packaging was a paid product placement – suitable brand integration with its new slogan “we will not tone it down”.

Meanwhile, the prevalence of digital media and popularity of social media allows Lady Gaga to interact directly with her fans and generate brand loyalty from her “Little Monsters”.  In fact, the official Little Monster greeting is an outstretched “Monster Claw” hand, allowing fans to identify and connect with each other.  Like any other brand, a consumer-centric strategy increases their loyalty to you.  Lady Gaga’s hit “Bad Romance” music video debuted on LadyGaga.com before MTV or any other media outlet could play it.   Before the Grammy awards, LadyGaga tweetedMy little monster sweeties are already camped outside today’s show!  I love u! Will be sending u pizza and water all day!“ At her concert last night, Lady Gaga called one of her fans from on stage and made her night.  Furthermore, Lady Gaga has been known to restrict professional photographers from capturing her performance and would rather her Little Monsters capture their own footage and share via social media.

In conclusion, Lady Gaga’s rise to fame is only partially attributed to musical talent.  The rest can be credited towards saavy marketing, consistent branding, a fan-centric approach, smart PR and strategic partnerships.  Looking forward to what comes next out of House of Gaga!

Real time Sync

Coca Cola Village 2010

August 18th, 2010 / Posted by: brett

Digital Buzz Blog reports a cutting edge Coca-Cola campaign out of Israel. In short, Coke Isreal brought the experience of being an exclusive invitee to a Coke branded teenage resort, the Coca Cola Village, (beach volleyball, spas, gaming, etc) to the winners friends via real time Facebook integration.

Step 1 was a Facebook contest for intivitations to the Coke Resort.  When the lucky winners arrived, they were given ID bracelets with their Facebook IDs pre-programmed via RFID. The bracelets were then used to ‘update their status on facebook’ as they interacted with various areas within the Coke Resort.

This is a fantastic example of how thinking digital early in the planning phase leads to highly integrated marketing programs. This execution obviously wasn’t cheap so budget must have been set aside early on to install the required place-based digital infrastructure that made this whole concept work more intuitively.

With digital agencies taking the lead more and more in the strategy phase, I’d argue that we will see bleeding edge concepts like this in retail and event environments more and more moving forward.

Brand Placement

...in Summer 2010 Blockbusters

July 26th, 2010 / Posted by: Vanessa

ET's Favorite Candy is Reece's PiecesProduct Placement in movies is a form of advertising where branded goods (or services) are placed in a context of the film and seen by the audience but usually without a blatent acknowledgement of the brand.

Perhaps the most classic example of product placement was in E.T. (1982) where a trail of Reese’s Pieces was used to lure the extraterrestrial out of hiding.  As a result, the candy’s sales soared ~65% after the movie’s release.  Other memorable Hollywood examples include Ray Ban sunglasses in Risky Business (1984) and Men in Black (1997) and FedEx and the Wilson Volleyball in Cast Away (2000) and the fast food chain in Harold and Kumar go to White Castle (2004).  Meanwhile, in TV, Crest’s Vanilla toothpaste product was placed on The Apprentice and the brand’s website was met with 4.7 million hits within 2 hours of the show.

Mr&MrsPotatoHeadAs for this summer, the Toy Story series is a reminder of how beneficial product placement can be in a storyline.  Would Toy Story be as relatable to its audience if Mr. and Mrs. Potato Head were unbranded toy vegetables, Etch-a-Sketch a generic drawing toy, and if Slinky the dog had another name? To put the power of product placement in perspective, after the first Toy Story’s debut, Mr. Potato Head sales increased by 800%, Etch a Sketch by 4500% and Slinky, out of business for 10 years was revived with 20,000 orders and has sold over $27 million (US) worth of the toy since.

According to Brand Cameo, here are some brand sightings (whether as a result of an official placement or not) to notice in Summer 2010 blockbusters:

  • Inception: Coca-Cola, Ford, Hyundai, Mercedes, Range Rover
  • Despicable Me: Cheetos, Lehman Brothers, MSNBC, NBC, Nintendo Wii
  • Twilight Eclipse: American Eagle Outfitters, Jeep, Nike, Porsche, The North Face, Volvo, Zippo
  • Toy Story 3: Apple, Barbie, Corvette, eBay, FisherPrice, GI Joe, Monopoly, Mr. Potato Head, Sharpie, Super Glue
  • The Karate Kid: Adidas, Air China, Audi, Converse, Haagen-Daaz, Los Angeles Lakers, Nike, Sony, Spongebob SquarePants, Volkswagen

Brand awareness and brand reinforcement are key benefits to product placement.  There is an implied endorsement of the product as millions of viewers see actors using (drinking, wearing, driving, etc.) the product and Hollywood has a relatively strong influence on its fans.  Alternatively, some further suggestions for product placement include using it as a testing ground for new products or to plant previews before a campaign launch.  Also, product placements in movies could be used to demonstrate the features of the product (wow – I didn’t know James Bond’s BMW could drive like that!). Lastly, the longevity of brand appearances in films live on beyond the cinema screening; aside from a theatre showing, these appearances will eventually live on DVDs, reruns, and airline showings.  With these thoughts in mind, you’ll never see a film the same way again!

Social Media Metrics

A Review of Two Analysis Frameworks

July 21st, 2010 / Posted by: brett

Social media reached 74% of the U.S. population for 6 hours and 28 minutes this April, according to Nielsen.  The 500,000,000 million pound Gorilla, Facebook, will reportedly reach the 500,000,000 user mark later this week. These numbers, along with general growth in internet usage, are the reasons that the global internet advertising spend is expected to grow 13.1% this year despite the slow pace of the economy.

This shift in dollars increases the volume on the question agencies and marketers have been asked over and over again for the last three to five years:  ‘What’s the ROI on my social media marketing program?’

A Google search will reveal dozens of formulas and experts trying to solve this problem. I looked at two recent approaches from a critical point of view: The ROI of Social Media Marketing by Augie Ray of Forrester Research (July 2010) and The Value of a Facebook Fan: an empirical review by Syncapse (June 2010).

Syncapse

Syncapse’s study was a comparative analysis of Facebook Fans versus non fans intended to determine, amongst other things,  the financial value of a fan (now a like).  The social media research company asked 4,000 respondents (fans and non-fans) questions relating to purchase intent, brand, and social media usage. The fans were from the twenty top brand pages on Facebook. How the non-fans were recruited was not described.

The System: Determine the financial value of a fan through six categories:

i.                Product spending (purchase intent and past purchases).

ii.              Brand loyalty (will you buy again)

iii.             Propensity to recommend (word of mouth).

iv.             Brand affinity (emotional connection)

v.              Earned media value (using paid media lens)

vi.             Acquisition cost (paid media spend, social media outreach  hours)

Survey data, available brand marketing data and “propriety formulas” were used to come up with a score that gave proxy values to earned media activity. The study determined that, on average, a fan is worth $136 (based on purchase intent and  exposure generated from average activity). Other findings include the insight that different verticals variad in terms of the difference in value between fans and non fans.

syncapse_findings_graph

All findings can be read here

Forrester

Forrester’s piece is critical review of some of the methods used to measure social media results and a recommended framework for moving forward. The research and insight leader points out that the term ROI is a financial term and should not be used as a synonym for the results.

The System: Shift away from strictly short term financial metric thinking to a more holistic understanding of the impact of social media marketing along four categories:

Forrester_scorecardi. Financial: Forrester advocates using financial metrics for products that have e-commerce platforms but says marketers should shy away from creating  proxy values (example: a Facebook like is the equivalent to $X dollars based on the fact the paid media value of that amount of reach is $Y dollars.) Other sales ROI considerations included:

  • Analyze online conversions with a grain of salt. Whether its display media traffic or a Facebook fan, a conversion is much more complex than the last touch-point made before purchasing something online.
  • Short term conversions do not show the impact that a program may have in the long term (both positively and negatively).
  • The money that social media platforms save in terms of not having to build a customer service and/or public relations platform is difficult to determine but should be factored in.

Purchase intent of a fan may have been similar if Facebook did not exist (but we now have a window into that customer’s world). 

ii. Brand: A mix of web analytics and traditional survey research should be factored in to determine brand health as a result of a social media program.  Factors like:

  • Awareness
  • Emotional connection
  • Loyalty
  • Engagement

iii. Digital impact: How has a given social media program impacted a brand’s digital footprint on a whole? Specifically:

  • Traffic to owned media
  • SEO performance
  • Earned media impact in other social venues (Tools like Radian6).

iv. Risk management: What are the costs of mitigating negative user feedback? How can social media be used to solve public relations problems started elsewhere in the company.

The four pillars of Forrester’s scorecard offer a comprehensive, longitudinal understanding of the impact of social media marketing.

Report Card:

The two systems of measurement cross-over and differ in many respects. Sydcapse attempts to directly answer the question of financial ROI whereas Forrester takes a step back to look at the validity of the question itself. Both rely on a blend of qualitative and quantitative data sources including web metrics, sales, and traditional survey measurement and evaluation.

Syncapse’s attempt to place monetary value on earned media, while left undisclosed, is interesting because it can be great ammunition for providing the value of digital word of mouth compared to paid display media. Nonetheless, Forrester’s framework is stronger because a) it can be adopted more easily by brands and agencies without propriety formulas and b) it factors in a more sophisticated understanding of the holistic digital marketing eco-system over time.

Blog Virgin!

July 19th, 2010 / Posted by: Nadia

woman-screamingIf someone asked me to blog 5 years ago they would have received a slap, as I could only imagine it being slang for something devil-ish. The emergence and importance of blogging over the years has allowed people and business everywhere to have a voice…even ‘lil ol me!

Information today is more readily available then ever before and in some cases who you are buying from is equally important as what your buying. Blogs are used as a compass to measure success, talk about politics, the hippest, baddest newest shoes on the market, celebrity gossip or pretty much anything you want to rant about. It’s also a massive arena for people to tell the world about the experience they had or are currently having with a certain business…positive or negative. These opinions and experiences are as genuine as it gets.  If you provide a great service (whether it’s a tangible product or an experience), and if someone chirps up a rainbow of “amazings” on a blog, you are in GREAT SHAPE.

Here are a few that I have grown very fond of:

  • Trip Advisor – This site has probably led to the success or demise of many resorts around the world. What better way to find out if the destination you are heading to has had a current rat infestation, horrible food or bars that close early (I tremble at the thought!).
  • Pop Culture Junkie – For the bookworms in the house…this is a great blog that critiques some pretty interesting books. I can always go to chapters.ca and find varying opinions on different books, but this site seems to have some unique choices.
  • Creativity Ad News – This site has been my fav as of late. It’s an extremely informative and interesting site that offers oodles and oddles of news about the advertising industry. It offers some behind the scene juice about how some of the BEST commercials were made.
  • Bloggers’ Choice Awards – This is essentially a blog site about bloggers. It literally respresents people like you and I who have something compelling to chat about. The best blogs are chosen and catagorized, so you can browse to see what may interest you. Again, back to my point, blogging is a platform for people to discuss what they like/love/hate/might-not-hate or are on the fence about topics. It’s possible that their point of view may just allow you and I to take more of a stand on the topic of choice.

I will be honest and open with you, this is my first time blogging. It is as I always imagined…I’m nervous, sweaty palms..scared the blog-pros will laugh me off  this post. BUT I’m a fighter and I will keep you interested if only for a moment As for blogging and business, did you know that over 50% of blog enthusiasts will visit the websites of the blogs they read?  These are just a few good a reasons why you should be chatting about what you love or what you want other people to love!

Extending Google Analytics

But wait... there's more!

July 8th, 2010 / Posted by: Rich McMullan

Google Analytics offers webmasters a large suite of tools to measure and track site visits, users, conversions and other important metrics. As GA has risen to dominate the “free” analytics space, so have emerged many third-party products to extend and customize Google Analytics to offer more tailored functionality.

  1. Extend Google Analytics with JQuery:
    Modify the standard Google tracking code using the power of jQuery to get extra information from your Google Analytics reports. With jQuery, Google Analytics can track your file downloads and clicks to external sites without having to trawl through your code and write any extra mark up.
    Read more >

  2. Dynamically update PowerPoint graphs with Google Analytics data:
    ShufflePoint Studio allows you to associate PowerPoint text, table, and chart placeholders with refreshable Google Analytics data. Use the provided slide templates to quickly create a presentation with your data. Define and format your data using the powerful ShufflePoint Analytics Query Language.
    Read more
    >
  3. Explore Analytics Data with JuiceKit visualizations:
    Keyword visualization of ZombieSingles.com

    Keyword visualization of ZombieSingles.com

    Juice has been working on their own open-source visualization framework, JuiceKit, that integrates the goodness of Flare with Adobe Flex. The results allow site owners using Google Analytics to see their data in a completely different context.
    Read More >

  4. Automate Analytics import into Excel Spreadsheets:
    GA Data Grabber is an advanced data visualization and analysis tool that eliminates manual data processing work and leads to significant time-savings. Used for quickly checking the latest figures, for automating regular KPI reporting, and for in-depth ad-hoc analysis. Works within MS Excel.
    Read More >

Digital Gooooals from South Africa

June 30th, 2010 / Posted by: Amy

World Cup fever has overtaken pubs, Little Italys, and office cubicles around the world and Noise is no exception.  With the festive occasion comes the influx of creative ad campaigns as brands attempt to use this international event to capitalize on new consumers and build their brand personality.

Here are a few online goodies from World Cup 2010 that have scored with us.

Nike: Write Your HeadlinePicture 1

After having already become the viral darling of South Africa 2010 with their epic three-minute “Write the Future” film, Nike has launched the largest ever LED installation with 90m high images of the world’s favourite football stars on Johannesburg’s Life Center Tower.

For this stunt, fans submit their own headlines via Facebook or Twitter (#nikefuture) and, each night, 100 are chosen to light up the city. And for a personal touch, winning fans are sent a replica animation of what was projected.

Visa – Go Fans on YouTube

Picture 4

Visa has created a terrific visual way to instantly build an online community, inviting football fans to share their passionate and hilarious cries of victory on the newly launched Go Fans YouTube Channel.  Click on “Worldwide Goooal” and you’ll hear the continuous stream of user-submitted videos and their goal shouts.

Originally made famous by Argentinean sportscaster Andrés Cantor, Cantor himself is the first video you see in the montage and also provides a brief cheeky online tutorial on perfecting the art of the “Goooal” shout.

La Hinchada Mas Grande Del MundoPicture 6

Chile may be small but its football fans are known as some of the feistiest.  This microsite allows you to connect with Chileans around with world using Google Maps technology to point out the location of other Chile supporters.

Users create a mini-social profile for themselves and are able to link to their Facebook, Twitter, and MSN.

Groupons, not Coupons

Put away your scissors, coupon snipping is not necessary in this digital day and age.

June 16th, 2010 / Posted by: Vanessa

Coupon and Scissors

Launched in 2008, Groupon is a group discount website – for things to see, eat and do. The website relies on reaching a critical mass tipping point before daily deals are unlocked to specific cities. It’s a win-win situation for everyone: business owners are guaranteed a minimum number of sales (with the incentive to offer better deals for more participants) and exposure to new clients, and in exchange, consumers get a great deal from a Groupon-approved company.

The Vancouver city launch of Groupon was at the end of April, with $20 for $40 worth of seafood at A Kettle of Fish restaurant. The deal “tipped” at 8:03am, with 25 people committed to buying a Groupon. Your credit card isn’t charged until the tipping point is reached. By the end of the day, a total of 383 Groupons were bought.

According to Mashable, the social buying site Groupon is now valued at more than $1 billion, joining few other Web 2.0 Startups (including Facebook and Twitter) which have crossed that financial threshold. Groupon demonstrates the power of collective action, and as digital media expands we will be seeing more of a consumer-driven market. Already with social media, increased power lies with the consumer as our voices get heard. User reviews, service rating sites, personal opinion blogs as a popular media source signify that consumer voices are being heard louder and faster than ever before.

Other discount websites following a similar business model for Vancouver residents include Wag Jag and Steal the Deal. My prediction is that “group buying” will be a fairly compelling trend for the rest of this year so jump aboard, check it out and give collective buying a chance – I’ll be seeing you at one of our city hotspots in the near future!

The Future is When?

June 9th, 2010 / Posted by: milardo

12vinc.large1 As someone anxiously awaiting my Marty McFly hoverboard, the future just can’t come soon enough. After the stunning technological disappointments of the 90’s (helllooo Virtual Reality anyone?) the last decade has had its fair share of real breakthroughs. So instead of harping on the past, let’s take a stab at something I am completely unqualified for – future forecasting! Some big developments that made my imagination tingle are…

Blade Runner Cityscapes!

It seems the massive wall sized video billboards of Deckard’s L.A. are in the process of getting a huge overhaul. We’ve been seeing tons of examples of 3D projection mapping, smart projectors that will give advertisers and artists the potential to do fantastic environmental-based visualizations. Or really colorful eyesores. Jury’s still out.

Genetic Manufacturing!

Another fave! If years of watching science fiction films have taught me anything, it’s that nothing good can come from manufacturing synthetic life forms. And yet, people are actually doing it. For money! Reservations aside, I’m actually looking forward to the day when I can build my Cat-Horse and ride it work.

Smart Robots!

We all know how this one turns out. Luckily, it seems we’re still quite a ways from Skynet’s global domination. Even though this is a couple years old, I’d be lying if I said these Big Dog’s still don’t give me the creeps. Seriously, these robotic soldier support units are pretty terrifying. Can’t you just see one of these murder death dogs lumbering over a hill brisling with machine guns? I can too, in my nightmares. On the brighter side, we can look at a more recent breakthrough in AI – robots that ‘learn’ how to fold towels. Supposedly, this is harder than it sounds.

Teleportation!

Leave it to China to break the record for farthest ‘teleportation’. In their quest to one-up the Internet, they have succeeded in ‘teleporting’ photons 10 miles from one port to another, using entangled photons. Whatever that means. So when do we do get to ‘teleport’ people? And why do I always seem to put ‘teleport’ in quotes? Anyone?